So, if a school's long term goal is 100%, then the only way to get there is by obsessing over short-term 100%s--at the semester, quarterly, weekly, and daily levels. And it then follows that the only way to help 100% of a classroom's students master a lesson objective is to engage 100% of them in meaningful practice of that objective and in high-level questioning about their new learning.
Now, think about a typical classroom's whole group instruction. A teacher asks a question and an excited student or two raise their hands to answer it. If your class size is 24, then you just engaged a mere 8% in answering your question. You then have a brief practice activity that you call 4 or 5 students to come up and participate in while the others watch. You just engaged 21% of your class in meaningful practice of the lesson objective while the remaining 79% remained, essentially, mentally and physically disengaged. You are especially careful to shelter your second language learners--you don't ask them questions or engage them in whole group practice as it might be difficult for them to handle making a language mistake in front of their peers. More than likely your ELLs (or SLLs) know they'll never be asked to do things during whole group (or at least to do difficult things!) so a good 100% of them have no need to really try and understand your instruction. You then send the children to their desks to do some independent work, hoping that 100% will master the objective. However, only roughly half are able to do so (remember, only a small handful actually engaged in meaningful practice during your whole group instruction!) and you might chalk it up to the fact that the other half simply wasn't ready to master that yet, or any other number of reasons why such a small number mastered the lesson objective. I know...I've occasionally thought those same things!
Instead, every student deserves to be taught by a teacher who literally obsesses over 100%--cien por ciento. Whole group instruction should include multiple opportunities for 100% of students to engaged in meaningful practice of the lesson objective. Here's an article that points out a few ways to accomplish this and the positive outcomes that they produce: Click here Will every child be ready to show mastery immediately? Nope. Prior knowledge/skill, developmental readiness, etc do have an impact on a child's readiness to master a skill, but the job of excellent teachers is to accelerate the journey from where children are to where they need to be. We need to plan additional supports to help the children we already know will likely struggle (alternative approaches, scaffolding, modifications, sheltered instruction for language learners, etc). How children get there might look a little different based on individual need, but 100% means somehow every child ends up getting there. We have mountains of evidence that tells us great teachers are able to help all children get there, even when others around them felt that a particular child or group of children wasn't ready or capable. It's all about the teacher and all about a total commitment to 100%.
Here are some easy ways to engage 100% of children in simultaneous practice of a lesson objective. These can also be quick and easy checks for understanding to help you informally assess student knowledge and skills throughout and at the end of a lesson.
- Whiteboards for children to write answer and show simultaneously
- Hand signals & body kinesthetics (thumbs up/down, sign language to show letter choices, "touch your head if it's living, touch your feet if it's non-living," etc)
- Signal cards (colored cards, letters on popsicle sticks, different pictures, etc)
- Human sorts (ex: "I'm going to show you pictures of different natural resources. I've put up three signs on three different walls of the classroom. If you think a resource is renewable go to that wall. If it's non-renewable go to this wall. If it's inexaustible, then go to the far wall." etc)
- Electronic clickers
- Exit slips
- Turn & talk to answer question with a partner
- Think, pair, share
- Clock partners
- Clipboards for children to jot answers on while on rug
- Chalk Talk
- Here are some non-questioning techniques from Teach For America that are great for practice/checking for understanding
- Teach Like a Champion, by Doug Lemov also has lots of techniques you can use (and a DVD full of video clips with teachers modeling them) to increase rigor and ensure all students are on the path to mastery
This is a great blog for a great cause! Good luck to you in your efforts to promote bilingualism in Texas and elsewhere.
ReplyDeleteI blog about language immersion education for the documentary film Speaking in Tongues (airing this month on PBS and streaming on the PBS website through Sept. 17) and have two kids in a Mandarin immersion program in a San Francisco public school. You can check out my blog at www.speakingintonguesfilm.info/our-blog/ I think you may find some useful information there, and I'd be happy to repost some of your work, too.
Thanks so much Abigail! I'll check out your blog right away.
ReplyDelete